| The Historian 2006-08-02, 10:40 pm |
|
Chess One wrote:
quote:
> "The Historian" <Spamscone@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:1145764899.572764.29080@u72g2000cwu.googlegroups.com...
>
> Adorjan is such a cheap-skate author, no? He provides probably the deepest
> game analysis from any GM in all of chess, and to the extent that it might
> be worth mentioning to anyone innocnetly reading this material, that he was
> the trainer to Kasparov and Leko. Not bad qualifications!
I made no comment about the author or his analysis. I merely pointed
out the book reviewer, one Phil Innes, failed to criticize the
analysis. From your response one can conclude the Innes book reviewing
standard can be summed up thus -
"The higher the rating, the better the book."
quote:
> But lets escape into this //diversion// even further - who next will Brennan
> attack in his rage against knowledge? Maybe like help-bot he will see fit to
> negatively mention even patzer-Kasparov
Gary Kasparov is a great chessplayer. However, if he wrote a poor book,
he should be criticized for it. I recall Richard Forster, a real IM,
Mr. Innes, not a Nearly one, has criticized some Kasparov analysis.
Should IM Forster be dismissed as a reviewer also?
quote:
> R
> O
>
> F
>
>
> L
>
>
> !
>
>
> !
>
>
> I am a poor second to yourself in this respect - you are obsessed by it! And
> its not braggadocio, its what it was!
As stated. Thanks for making my point.
quote:
>
> I will oblige all readers by writing Adorjan's own comments here, about
> myself and other reviewers - once, of course, we deal with the current
> issue!
>
> The current issue addresses who can even understand the need to analyse
> games in order to make chessic comments about them. What does Taylor
> Kingston think he is about? We see a group of people who can freely
> criticise GMs at chess making very slight and slighting references, but who
> are unable even to look at a chess diagram of their own choice either
> chessically understand it, or historically note that the position is
> infamous.
Snip more Innesian nonsense.
|